Public examination event

Organising the public examination event, making dissertation press release and the course of the public examination event

The stages of the examination process are preliminary examination, permission for public examination, decision on the public examination, publishing the dissertation, organising the public examination event and making dissertation press release, public examination event and the assessment of the doctoral dissertation.

Please note that you need to be registered as an attending for the semester during which you defend your doctoral thesis and the dissertation is registered in the study register.

Before the Public Examination of the Dissertation

Organising the public examination event

The procedure and formalities for the public examination of the dissertation may vary between faculties, so please also check the guidelines of your own faculty, which can be found at the bottom of this page.

The Custos appointed by the Faculty Council is the official supervisor of the public examination, with whom the details of the event are agreed. The doctoral candidate must not be in contact with the Opponent before the public examination of the dissertation. Communication with the opponent is done through the Custos. 

Remember that in addition to organising the dissertation examination event, it is important to take care of the publication and distribution of your dissertation.

You can prepare for the public examination of your dissertation by thinking about what questions the Opponent might ask. Public examination is rarely an examination to the letter. The dissertations is usually no longer rejected at this stage.

Announcing your dissertation

We publish news about dissertations in a question-and-answer format on the university website.

  • The news item briefly summarises the key findings of the dissertation in plain language.
  • The news item is directed to the general public, and when writing it, you should consider what aspects of the dissertation might be of interest to the general public.
  • The news item should be no longer than 2,000 characters.
  • Write a headline that clearly states the main result of the research in an interesting way. A good headline is important because it determines whether the reader will continue reading.
  • Write a single sentence in the lead that states your name and what the research is about, with a maximum of 200 characters.
  • Answer the following questions in the news item:
    • What did you study?
    • What were the results of your study or what is its main finding?
    • How can the results be applied? What new insights did the research contribute to the topic?
  • You can use AI tools to help you edit the text. Link to the University of Jyväskylä’s AI policy.
  • The news item should be written in Finnish. If your doctoral dissertation is in English, please also write the item in English. If you cannot write in Finnish, you can write it in English only.
  • At the end of the item, include the details of the public defence and a link if the event is accessible remotely. If the dissertation is conducted remotely, add the custos’s phone number in case the audience has any questions. This section does not count towards the amount of characters.
  • Include a link to the dissertation if it has been published online.
  • Include your contact information.
  • Send the news item to viestinta@jyu.fi at least three weeks before the public defence. We will publish it on our website about a week before the event.
  • Example of a news item: | University of Jyväskylä

Photo

  • The news item should also include a photo. A photo taken with a phone is acceptable, as long as it is of a sufficient size (resolution 300 dpi). A landscape photo works best on websites. Remember to include the name of the photographer.
  • You can also have your photo taken at a Star Image studio in Jyväskylä or at one of their other locations in Helsinki, Tampere or Turku. No appointment is necessary. Ask for a so-called “yearbook photo” (matrikkelikuva in Finnish). Please mention that the photo and invoice are to be sent to the University of Jyväskylä Communications: viestinta@jyu.fi.
  • Please note that by using the Star Image service, you also accept that your photo can be used on the university’s social media channels and website. Your photo will be stored in the university’s image bank for four years. The photo will be archived to accompany your dissertation announcement and for possible future media distributions and inquiries. The studio will send the photo directly to University Communications.

Media communication

  • For some dissertations, we will also send a press release to the media. The criteria for this include societal relevance and impact as well as general interest. Your faculty’s communications specialist will contact you and help you edit and distribute the press release based on the news item you prepared. 

Public examination of the dissertation

The examination event is an open public event, where the dissertation is examined. The public examinations of doctoral dissertations at the University of Jyväskylä follow traditional customs and forms, which may vary between disciplines and change over time. The general structure of the examination and generally used phrases are as follows:

1. The doctoral candidate, Custos and Opponent arrive into the hall 15 minutes past the official starting time of the public examination. The doctoral candidate arrives into the hall first, then the Custos and then the Opponent. The audience remains standing up. During the entry and exit the Custos and the Opponent hold their Doctor's hats, if they have one, in their left hand so that the lyre is facing forward. During the public examination, the hats are placed in the table.

2. When all are seated, the Custos introduces the doctoral candidate, the title of the dissertation, as well as the Opponent. Then the Custos declares the public examination of the dissertation open by saying "As the Custos appointed by the faculty I declare this public examination opened."

3. The doctoral candidate delivers his/her lectio praecursoria (introductory lecture) standing, not exceeding 20 minutes, by first addressing the Custos, then the Opponent and then the audience. The presentation must be started with the words "Distinguished Custos, honoured Opponent, ladies and gentlemen."

4. After the lectio praecursoria, the doctoral candidate will, still standing, ask the Opponent to present the critical comments. The request is done by saying: "Honoured professor (doctor, etc.), as the opponent appointed by the faculty, please present the comments that you see my dissertation has given grounds for."

5. The Opponent stands up and makes a short statement, in which they deal with issues such as the position and importance of the thesis within its field of study, and other general issues. After the statement both the doctoral candidate and the Opponent sit down.

6. In the beginning of the actual public examination the Opponent focuses first on the methodological and general questions. The general examination is followed by a detailed examination.

7. The Opponent makes a concluding statement after the detailed examination. The opponent presents their final statement while standing, and the doctoral candidate listens to the statement standing up. At the end of the concluding statement, the opponent states whether they will recommend that the faculty approve the dissertation. 

8. Still standing up, the doctoral candidate thanks the Opponent, who may then sit down.

9. The doctoral candidate turns to face the audience and solicits those people present (so called extra opponents) who might have some critical comments to step forward and ask for an address from the Custos. Soliciting is done by saying: "If anyone here has any critical comments to make on my dissertation, please ask the Custos for the floor." After this the doctoral candidate sits down.

10. The Custos presides the situation by giving addresses and they also make sure that the doctoral candidate gets the opportunity to answer all the questions. The Custos also attends to the fact the addresses given do not digress from the subject. Usually addresses are not requested. If a comment is made about violation of research integrity, the Custos writes the comment down or, if the comment is long and detailed, requests the comment in writing by a due date in the same form and extent as it was presented in the public examination. Possible comments must be investigated, clarified and reported to the faculty council. The faculty council may postpone decision on the matter until further clarifications have been made.

11. The Custos closes the public examination, standing up, by saying: "The public examination is now concluded." At most, the public examination can last 4 hours. Usually the examination takes ca 2 to 2 ½ hours.

12. The doctoral candidate, the Custos, and the opponents leave the hall in the same order they arrived in. The audience stands up.

The examination should be high-level conversation between two experts of the field, about the interesting themes of the doctoral thesis. Enlightened laymen should also be able to follow the conversation and it should give them things to consider. As a public occasion, public examinations are visible illustrations of the university life.

After the public examination of the dissertation

This section lists things that happen after the dissertation examination. Please note, however, that the list contains things that must be planned before the public examination event.

The supplementary instructions of the Faculties